February
2009 | by Art Olson, Primavera
Supplementary
material exclusive
to the website
One
of the most impactful
projects on
the City’s
active agenda is the
undergrounding of
neighborhood utilities.
Over 450 Del Mar homes
are currently being
evaluated for what
would amount to a
project totaling over
$12 million. The North
Hills Undergrounding
area is comprised
of three assessment
districts that cover
much of the hill residences
from Serpentine Drive
on the north to Eighth
Street on the south.
The Sunset Undergrounding
District covers most
of the remaining hill
homes north of Serpentine
and east of Camino
Del Mar. The planning
and implementation
process is a complex
one, which began in
June 2007 with an
initial petition phase
that gained City Council
approval. Subsequent
steps involve: utility
design, assessment
reports, neighborhood
coordination, specification
and bidding, balloting,
public hearings and
construction. The
original schedule
had projected that
the assessment phase
would be completed
by the end of January,
but according to Ernesto
Aguilar, the City’s
Assessment Engineer,
delays in the utility
designs have pushed
that date back by
at least 7 weeks.
While
it is appears that an
overwhelming majority
of homeowners desire
the safety, reliability
and aesthetic benefits
of utility undergounding,
concerns have been raised
regarding the assessment
methodology, and visual
impacts of the project.
A group of homeowners
in the Sunset District
have questioned the
fairness of the currently
proposed Del Mar assessment
formula as applied to
their district. They
argue that the current
method, which was used
in the now completed
Ocean Pines Undergrounding
District, is not suitable
for the complex topography
and lot boundaries of
their district. Bill
Lewis and Don Smith,
members of this group,
have analyzed the current
methodology, comparing
it with Solana Beach
and other cities. An
article by them is available
on the Sandpiper web
site (www.delmarsandpiper.org).
Another
voiced concern regards
the appearance of the
utility boxes that will
exist above ground after
the undergrounding is
completed. According
to John Weare,
|
Illustrations
by Bill Lewis |
homeowner
in the Ocean Pines district,
while residents there
are generally quite
happy about the aesthetic
improvement from pole
and wire removal, they
were surprised by the
negative visual impact
of the utility boxes
installed in their neighborhood.
Denise Nagata, another
Ocean Pines resident
and former Design Review
Board Member agreed,
and felt that most people
were focused on assessment
issues and did not consider
the aesthetics of the
utility boxes prior
to their installation.
Architect Bill Lewis
has examined alternative
designs to mitigate
their stark industrial
look while providing
the required access,
by screening the boxes
with decorative walls
that better harmonize
with the character of
the neighborhood.
Thus,
while most Del Mar residents
want to see their utilities
undergrounded, some
feel that in order to
move successfully toward
that goal there are
issues of fairness and
aesthetics that should
be considered in light
of others’ past
experiences and individual
neighborhood characteristics.

Note: This
material did not appear
in the print edition.
Sunset
District Analysis
Case
Study A
Lot
14 Comparison
Case
Study B
Lot
29 Comparison
|